In a certain emergency rescue service, seven workers F, G, H, I, J, K and L are assigned to accompany three mobile trauma vans during a single 12-hour shift. Each worker must be assigned to just one of the vans according to the following rules:
At least two workers must be assigned to van 1.
At least three workers, one of whom must be J, must be assigned to van 3.
If F is assigned to van 1, I must also be assigned to van 1.
G must be assigned to van 2.
L cannot be assigned to van 3.
Question 1
Which of the following is a possible assignment of the seven workers to the three vans?
Van 1 / Van 2 / Van 3 (A) F / G, H, I / J, K, L (B) F, I / G, J / H, K, L (C) F, G / I, L / H, J, K (D) I, L / G, F / H, J, K (E) I, G / H, L / F, J, K
F in Van 1; G, H, I in Van 2; J, K, L in Van 3
F, I in Van 1; G, J in Van 2; H, K, L in Van 3
F, G in Van 1; I, L in Van 2; H, J, K in Van 3
I, L in Van 1; G, F in Van 2; H, J, K in Van 3
I, G in Van 1; H, L in Van 2; F, J, K in Van 3
Show answer & solution
Answer: (D) I, L in Van 1; G, F in Van 2; H, J, K in Van 3
Apply the excluding rule: option A fails rule 1 (only one worker in van 1). Option B fails rule 2 (van 3 has L, which is not allowed there, and lacks enough workers properly assigned). Option C fails rule 3 (F is in van 1 but I is not). Option E fails rule 4 (G is not in van 2). Option D, with I and L in van 1, G and F in van 2, and H, J and K in van 3, satisfies every rule. Option D is correct.
Question 2
If I is assigned to van 2, which of the following must be true?
F is assigned to van 1.
K is assigned to van 3.
H is assigned to van 1.
H is assigned to van 3.
L is assigned to van 1.
Show answer & solution
Answer: (E) L is assigned to van 1.
If I is in van 2, rule 3 (F in van 1 requires I in van 1) means F cannot be in van 1. Rule 2 requires J in van 3, and G must be in van 2 (rule 4), alongside I. Rule 5 bars L from van 3, and rule 1 requires at least two workers in van 1 — since F, G, I, J are all placed elsewhere, L must be in van 1 to help satisfy rule 1. Option E is correct.
Question 3
If F and L are assigned to van 1, all of the following must be true EXCEPT:
H is assigned to van 2.
K is assigned to van 3.
Exactly one worker is assigned to van 2.
Exactly three workers are assigned to van 1.
Exactly three workers are assigned to van 3.
Show answer & solution
Answer: (A) H is assigned to van 2.
With F and L in van 1, rule 3 forces I into van 1 too (F, L, I). Rule 2 puts J in van 3, rule 4 puts G in van 2, and the remaining workers H and K must fill out van 3 to reach at least three there, giving van 3 = J, H, K. That makes van 2 = G alone (one worker), van 1 = F, L, I (three workers), and van 3 = J, H, K (three workers). H ends up in van 3, not van 2, so 'H is assigned to van 2' does not have to be true. Option A is correct.
Question 4
If I and L are the only workers assigned to van 1, which of the following is the largest group of workers that could possibly be assigned to van 3?
G, H
H, K
F, J, K
F, H, J, K
G, H, J, K
Show answer & solution
Answer: (D) F, H, J, K
With I and L fixed in van 1, rule 2 puts J in van 3 and rule 4 puts G in van 2. That leaves F, H and K unassigned, and since van 1 is already fixed at I and L only, none of F, H or K can join van 1 — they must go to van 2 or van 3. The largest possible van 3 group adds all three of F, H and K to J, giving F, H, J, K. Option D is correct.
Question 5
If exactly three workers are assigned to van 1, which of the following must be true?
F is assigned to van 3.
I is assigned to van 1.
K is assigned to van 1.
F is assigned to the same van as I.
G alone is assigned to van 2.
Show answer & solution
Answer: (E) G alone is assigned to van 2.
With exactly three workers in van 1 and at least three required in van 3 (rule 2), the remaining workers must split so that van 2 ends up with only G, since van 1 and van 3 together already account for six of the seven workers. Option E is correct.
Question 6
If I is the only worker not yet assigned, and if, at this point, I could be assigned to any one of the three vans, which of the following must be true?
F is assigned to van 1.
H is assigned to van 1.
H is assigned to van 3.
K is assigned to van 3.
L is assigned to van 1.
Show answer & solution
Answer: (E) L is assigned to van 1.
For I to be free to join any of the three vans, van 2 must not already be full — since van 2 can hold at most two workers and G is already required there (rule 4), van 2 has room for exactly one more, which I could fill. Rule 2 already places J in van 3, and since L cannot go to van 3 (rule 5) and van 1 needs at least two workers (rule 1) that aren't dependent on I, L must be assigned to van 1. Option E is correct.