Engineering, Management, Agriculture and Veterinary MCQs are now live. FPSC, PPSC, EPE, IELTS & GRE coming soon.

Committee Selection Logic Games

NTS GAT General · Analytical

9 questions, each with the answer and a worked solution. Questions follow the rules of the logic game above them.

Practice interactively and track your score →

Senate Foreign Relations Subcommittee

A subcommittee of the senate's foreign relations committee consists of three republicans Rameez, Saad and Tahir and three democrats Waqas, Yawer and Zaheer. Three of these six senators need to visit Moscow to meet with Russian leaders. The decision as to which senators will make the trip is subject to the following conditions:

Question 1

Which of the following is a list of three senators who could make the trip together?

  1. Rameez, Yawer, Zaheer
  2. Rameez, Tahir, Yawer
  3. Rameez, Saad, Yawer
  4. Tahir, Waqas, Yawer
  5. Waqas, Yawer, Zaheer
Show answer & solution

Answer: (B) Rameez, Tahir, Yawer

Apply the excluding rule: option E breaks rule 1 (not all from the same party is violated when checked against Waqas/Zaheer's link — actually E fails rule 4's converse), option C breaks rule 2 (Rameez and Saad together), option A breaks rule 3 (Tahir without Yawer), option D breaks rule 4 (Waqas without Zaheer). So option B is correct.

Question 2

If Zaheer and Rameez are selected to make the trip, which of the following must be true?

  1. More democrats than republicans make the trip
  2. More republicans than democrats make the trip
  3. Saad makes the trip
  4. Tahir makes the trip
  5. Yawer makes the trip
Show answer & solution

Answer: (A) More democrats than republicans make the trip

Zaheer and Rameez are selected, so a 3rd member is needed. Saad cannot be selected (rule 2, since Rameez is already in). Tahir and Yawer only travel together (rule 3), but there is only one vacancy left, so neither can be selected. Hence the 3rd member must be Waqas. That gives two democrats (Waqas, Zaheer) and one republican (Rameez), so more democrats than republicans make the trip. Option A is correct.

Question 3

If the senate decides to send four of these senators, subject to the same conditions, all of the following must be true EXCEPT:

  1. Tahir makes the trip
  2. Yawer makes the trip
  3. Zaheer makes the trip
  4. Rameez or Saad makes the trip
  5. If Waqas makes the trip, then Rameez doesn't make the trip
Show answer & solution

Answer: (D) Rameez or Saad makes the trip

With four seats, the only valid committees are: Tahir+Yawer+Waqas+Zaheer, Tahir+Yawer+Rameez+Zaheer, and Tahir+Yawer+Saad+Zaheer. Tahir, Yawer and Zaheer appear in all three (so A, B and C must always be true), and option E holds in every case too. Option D only holds in two of the three possibilities, so it does not have to be true — making it the exception. Option D is correct.

Question 4

If more republicans than democrats make the trip, which of the following must be among the senators making the trip?

  1. Rameez
  2. Saad
  3. Waqas
  4. Yawer
  5. Zaheer
Show answer & solution

Answer: (D) Yawer

To have more republicans than democrats among three seats, the only two possible combinations are Rameez+Tahir (plus one more) or Saad+Tahir (plus one more). Tahir is selected in both, and since Tahir and Yawer travel together (rule 3), Yawer must also be selected. Option D is correct.

Question 5

If Waqas is selected for the trip, then which of the following members must be selected for the trip?

  1. Rameez
  2. Saad
  3. Zaheer
  4. Yawer
  5. Tahir
Show answer & solution

Answer: (C) Zaheer

Rule 4 states that Waqas will only make the trip if Zaheer does, so if Waqas is selected, Zaheer must also be selected. Option C is correct.

Vegetable Salad Selection

Three vegetables must be selected for a salad from six vegetables: carrot, chili, cucumber, onion, radish and tomato, according to the following conditions:

Question 6

Which of the following is an acceptable selection of vegetables for the salad?

  1. Carrot, chili and cucumber
  2. Carrot, cucumber and onion
  3. Carrot, cucumber and radish
  4. Chili, cucumber and radish
  5. Chili, onion and radish
Show answer & solution

Answer: (C) Carrot, cucumber and radish

Apply the excluding rule: option E breaks rule 1 (no carrot or cucumber), option B breaks rule 2 (no chili or radish), options D and A break rule 3 (chili together with cucumber or radish). So option C is correct.

Question 7

Which of the following pairs of vegetables CANNOT both be among the vegetables selected?

  1. Carrot and chili
  2. Carrot and onion
  3. Chili and tomato
  4. Onion and tomato
  5. Radish and tomato
Show answer & solution

Answer: (D) Onion and tomato

Options A and B fail rule 2 (neither pair includes chili or radish). Options C and E fail rule 1 (neither pair includes carrot or cucumber). Option D is correct — a pair that CAN'T stand alone as the full selection, since neither rule 1 nor rule 2 would be satisfied by onion and tomato alone.

Question 8

If cucumber is selected for the salad, which of the following must also be among the vegetables selected?

  1. Carrot
  2. Chili
  3. Onion
  4. Radish
  5. Tomato
Show answer & solution

Answer: (D) Radish

If cucumber is selected, chili cannot be selected (rule 3), so radish must be selected instead to satisfy rule 2. Option D is correct.

Question 9

If radish is not selected, which pair of vegetables must be among those selected?

  1. Carrot and chili
  2. Carrot and onion
  3. Carrot and tomato
  4. Chili and onion
  5. Chili and tomato
Show answer & solution

Answer: (A) Carrot and chili

If radish is not selected, chili must be selected to satisfy rule 2, and rule 1 requires carrot or cucumber (or both) to be selected — combined with rule 3 (chili can't go with cucumber), carrot must be the one selected alongside chili. Option A is correct.

Practice these 9 questions interactively →