In which case did the UK House of Lords set out a three-stage test for duty of care, often applied to auditors?
Show answer & solution
Answer: (C) Caparo Industries plc v Dickman (1990)
Foreseeability, proximity and fairness are required.
Auditing · Corporate Governance & Regulation
40 questions, each with the answer and a worked solution.
Practice interactively and track your score →In which case did the UK House of Lords set out a three-stage test for duty of care, often applied to auditors?
Answer: (C) Caparo Industries plc v Dickman (1990)
Foreseeability, proximity and fairness are required.
Which case established that liability for negligent misstatement may arise where a special relationship exists?
Answer: (A) Hedley Byrne & Co Ltd v Heller & Partners (1964)
It extended liability beyond contracts.
What is the auditor's main contractual liability?
Answer: (D) Liability to the client company for breach of contract or negligence in performing the audit
The contract is with the company.
What must a claimant prove to succeed in a negligence claim against an auditor?
Answer: (D) A duty of care existed, it was breached, and the breach caused a financial loss
All elements must be shown.
Why does the Caparo decision limit auditors' liability to potential investors?
Answer: (B) Statutory audit reports are prepared for shareholders as a body, not for individual investment decisions
Special relationships may create exceptions.
What is a "Bannerman" disclaimer?
Answer: (A) A disclaimer in an audit report stating that the auditor does not accept liability to third parties
It arose after the Royal Bank of Scotland v Bannerman case.
How can auditors manage their exposure to liability?
Answer: (C) Performing quality audits, using clear engagement letters, maintaining professional indemnity insurance and good documentation
Quality is the best defence.
What is professional indemnity insurance?
Answer: (D) Insurance that covers auditors against claims of professional negligence
It protects both the firm and claimants.
What is criminal liability of an auditor in company law?
Answer: (B) Liability for wilfully making false statements in reports or documents
Penalties include fines and imprisonment.
Within what period after the end of the financial year must a company hold its annual general meeting under the Companies Act 2017?
Answer: (C) Within one hundred and twenty days
The first AGM has a different time limit.
Within what period after incorporation must a company hold its first annual general meeting under the Companies Act 2017?
Answer: (A) Within sixteen months
Later AGMs are held annually.
For how long must a company preserve its books of account under the Companies Act 2017?
Answer: (C) At least ten years
Books must be kept at the registered office or approved place.
Within what period must a listed company prepare and circulate its first and third quarterly accounts under the Companies Act 2017?
Answer: (A) Within thirty days of the end of the quarter
They are placed on the company's website.
Within what period must a listed company prepare its half-yearly accounts after the end of the half-year under the Companies Act 2017?
Answer: (B) Within sixty days
They are reviewed by the auditor.
How many days' notice of an annual general meeting must normally be given to members of a listed company?
Answer: (D) At least twenty-one days
Audited accounts are sent with the notice.
What must accompany the audited financial statements laid before the AGM?
Answer: (C) The directors' report and the auditor's report
The chairman's review may also be included.
Which document must companies file with the SECP registrar after the AGM?
Answer: (A) The audited financial statements and annual return within the prescribed time
Late filing attracts penalties.
What is the purpose of the directors' responsibility statement in annual reports?
Answer: (D) Stating that directors are responsible for preparing the financial statements and maintaining controls
It clarifies responsibility for the accounts.
What is the liability of directors for false financial statements?
Answer: (B) Directors may face penalties and civil liability for knowingly approving false statements
Company law imposes duties on directors.
What is the main protection for auditors against unfair claims?
Answer: (D) Evidence in working papers showing that ISAs were properly followed
Documentation supports the defence.
What is "contributory negligence" in auditor liability cases?
Answer: (A) The client's own negligence that contributed to the loss and may reduce damages
Weak controls by the client may be relevant.
What is the purpose of "limited liability partnerships" for audit firms?
Answer: (B) Limiting partners' personal liability for claims not caused by them
Pakistan allows LLPs under the LLP Act 2017.
What is a "liability cap" in audit engagements?
Answer: (C) A contractual limit on the amount of damages an auditor may pay, where permitted by law
Statutory audits may restrict such caps.
What is meant by "joint and several liability" for auditors?
Answer: (A) Each defendant may be liable for the full loss, even if others share the blame
Proportionate liability reforms address this.
What is "proportionate liability"?
Answer: (D) Each party is liable only for its share of responsibility for the loss
Some countries have adopted it for auditors.
What is the auditor's responsibility for an investor who relied on audited accounts to buy shares in the market?
Answer: (C) Generally no duty of care unless a special relationship existed
This follows the Caparo principle.
What is the role of the SECP in enforcing financial reporting by companies?
Answer: (B) Reviewing financial statements and taking action for non-compliance with the Act and standards
SECP monitors listed and other companies.
Why are interim reports reviewed rather than audited?
Answer: (D) Review provides timely limited assurance at lower cost than a full audit
Annual statements are fully audited.
What is the consequence of late filing of financial statements by a company?
Answer: (C) Penalties under the Companies Act and possible action by the SECP
Timely filing supports transparency.
What is the main purpose of corporate reporting regulation?
Answer: (B) Ensuring reliable, timely and comparable information for investors and other users
It supports capital market confidence.
What is the auditor's duty when a company is suspected of insolvent trading?
Answer: (D) Considering going concern and reporting obligations, and communicating with those charged with governance
Directors may face personal liability.
What is the liability of auditors for reports given to banks for loan purposes?
Answer: (B) Auditors may owe a duty of care if they knew the bank would rely on the report for a specific purpose
A special relationship may arise.
What is "negligent misstatement"?
Answer: (B) A careless statement relied on by another person who suffers loss as a result
Hedley Byrne established liability for it.
What is the main defence available to an auditor in a negligence claim?
Answer: (D) Showing that the audit was performed with reasonable care and skill according to standards
Documentation supports the defence.
What is "limitation period" in negligence claims?
Answer: (C) The time within which a claim must be brought under the law
Claims after the period may be barred.
What is the significance of the ADT v BDO Binder Hamlyn case?
Answer: (A) An auditor's oral assurance to a prospective purchaser created a duty of care and liability
Specific assurances can create liability.
What is the significance of the Royal Bank of Scotland v Bannerman case?
Answer: (B) Auditors may owe a duty to a bank that relies on audited accounts if they know of the reliance and do not disclaim
It led to wider use of Bannerman disclaimers.
What is the role of corporate reporting deadlines in investor protection?
Answer: (C) Ensuring investors receive timely information for decisions
Late reporting reduces usefulness of information.
What does the Companies Act 2017 require regarding the laying of financial statements at the AGM?
Answer: (A) Audited financial statements with the directors' and auditor's reports must be laid before members
Members approve the statements.
Why are financial statements of listed companies placed on their websites?
Answer: (D) To make information easily accessible to investors and the public
The law requires website disclosure for listed companies.